What it disputes
-
Examiner’s Report on Lehman Brothers (Valukas)
EY’s last audit of Lehman was for the year ended 30 November 2007; it reviewed but did not audit the interim periods of fiscal 2008.Our opinion stated that Lehman's financial statements for 2007 were fairly presented in accordance with U.S. GAAP, and we remain of that view
1
Each side is quoted in its own words. Whether a finding holds is not decided here.
People v. Ernst & Young LLP, 451586/2010
- Settled with New York State Attorney General: $10M, settled New York’s civil lawsuit (filed December 2010); EY said there were “no findings of wrongdoing” 2345The suit alleged EY helped Lehman hide financial problems; it was a civil suit, not a criminal charge. EY separately agreed in December 2013 to pay $99 million to settle a federal class action by Lehman investors, and denied all liability to the plaintiffs.
SEC order on CPA ethics-exam cheating and EY’s misleading submission
- Settled with U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission: $100M, EY admitted the charges 67
Connections 7
member of
settled with
-
New York State Attorney General
15 Apr 2015
$10M, settled New York’s civil lawsuit (filed December 2010); EY said there were “no findings of wrongdoing”
Scholarship & press
2345
The suit alleged EY helped Lehman hide financial problems; it was a civil suit, not a criminal charge. EY separately agreed in December 2013 to pay $99 million to settle a federal class action by Lehman investors, and denied all liability to the plaintiffs.
- U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission 28 Jun 2022 $100M, EY admitted the charges Scholarship & press 67
contracts from
- Lehman Brothers auditor Primary record 10
involved in
- PCAOB inspection results for 2023 22 of 59 audits reviewed (37%) Scholarship & press 11
- PCAOB inspection results for 2024 18 of 64 audits reviewed (28%) Scholarship & press 12
disputes a finding of
-
Examiner’s Report on Lehman Brothers (Valukas)
25 Mar 2010
According to Ernst & Young LLP
Scholarship & press
1
EY’s last audit of Lehman was for the year ended 30 November 2007; it reviewed but did not audit the interim periods of fiscal 2008.
Timeline 3 dates
- 25 Mar 2010 Ernst & Young LLP disputes a finding of Examiner’s Report on Lehman Brothers (Valukas) According to Ernst & Young LLP
- 15 Apr 2015 Ernst & Young LLP settled with New York State Attorney General
- 28 Jun 2022 Ernst & Young LLP settled with U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission
Proof 12 sources
-
Ernst & Young Defends Lehman Audits, Accounting Today, 25 Mar 2010.
Scholarship & press
Our opinion stated that Lehman's financial statements for 2007 were fairly presented in accordance with U.S. GAAP, and we remain of that view
It was not caused by accounting issues or disclosure issues.
-
Attorney General Schneiderman Announces Settlement With Ernst & Young Over Auditor’s Involvement In Alleged Fraud At Lehman Brothers, Mondo Visione (reprint of a New York Attorney General release), 15 Apr 2015.
Scholarship & press
Under the terms of the settlement, Ernst & Young will pay $10 million—most of which will go to investors, with the remaining settlement funds to be used to reimburse New York State for investigation and litigation costs.
-
Ernst & Young Will Pay $10 Million to End N.Y. Lehman Suit, Accounting Today, 15 Apr 2015.
Scholarship & press
“pleased to put this matter behind us”
Ernst & Young LLP agreed to pay $10 million to settle New York’s lawsuit accusing it of helping Lehman Brothers Holdings Inc. hide financial problems in the years leading to its 2008 collapse.
-
Ernst & Young settles Lehman case for $10 million, CBS News, 15 Apr 2015.
Scholarship & press
The settlement of the state lawsuit, filed in 2010, closes out the first case filed against the auditor of a public company under New York securities laws, the Attorney General's office said.
-
Ernst & Young Settles Lehman Investor Lawsuit for $99 Million, Accounting Today, 2 Dec 2013.
Scholarship & press
Ernst & Young LLP agreed to pay investors $99 million to settle litigation over its auditing of the bankrupt Lehman Brothers Holdings Inc.
Ernst & Young denies all liability to the plaintiffs
-
Ernst & Young to pay $100-million to settle U.S. charges of staff cheating on accountant exams, The Globe and Mail (Reuters), 28 Jun 2022.
Scholarship & press
The London-based auditor admitted to the charges and agreed to pay what the SEC said is its largest fine against an auditor.
The Wall Street watchdog found that 49 EY professionals “obtained or circulated” answer keys to CPA licence exams, while hundreds of others cheated to complete the continuing professional education components relating to CPA ethics.
EY submitted to the SEC that it did not have issues with cheating when, in fact, the firm had been informed of potential cheating on a CPA ethics exam by a member of staff, the SEC said.
It added that EY admitted it did not correct its submission even after an internal EY investigation confirmed there had been cheating, and even after its senior lawyers discussed the matter with the firm’s senior management.
-
EY agrees record $100m settlement with US regulator over ethics exam cheating scandal, City A.M., 28 Jun 2022.
Scholarship & press
The US financial watchdog said in a statement that EY had agreed to pay the highest penalty ever imposed on an audit firm by the SEC
Our response to this unacceptable past behavior has been thorough, extensive, and effective.
-
Spotlight: Staff Update on 2024 Inspection Activities, Public Company Accounting Oversight Board, Mar 2025.
Primary record
U.S. GNF – These firms are headquartered in the U.S. and are members of global networks through which they affiliate with firms in other countries for various business and client service purposes.
-
Spotlight: Staff Update on 2023 Inspection Activities, Public Company Accounting Oversight Board, Aug 2024.
Primary record
The Big Four accounting firms are commonly known to be Deloitte & Touche LLP (“Deloitte”), Ernst & Young LLP (“EY”), KPMG LLP (“KPMG”), and PricewaterhouseCoopers LLP (“PwC”).
-
Lehman Brothers Holdings Inc. Chapter 11 Proceedings Examiner's Report (Anton R. Valukas), Vols 1, 3, 5, Examiner, U.S. Bankruptcy Court S.D.N.Y. (official site jenner.com/lehman returned 404 to curl; copies from Stanford mirror), 11 Mar 2010.
Primary record
Lehman’s auditors, Ernst & Young, were aware of but did not question Lehman’s use and nondisclosure of the Repo 105 accounting transactions.
-
PCAOB sees audit deficiencies leveling off at largest firms, but problems remain, Accounting Today, 15 Aug 2024.
Scholarship & press
At Ernst & Young LLP , 22 of the 59 audits reviewed in 2023 were included in Part I.A.
-
PCAOB sees improvements in largest audit firms, Accounting Today, 31 Mar 2025.
Scholarship & press
At Ernst & Young LLP , 18 of the 64 audits reviewed by the PCAOB in 2024 were included in Part I.A of this report due to the significance of the deficiencies identified, a 28% Part I.A deficiency rate.
Page history 1 change
- Add 55 stories, each checked against its sources96e92fe6
Something wrong or missing? Tell us, with a source, or edit this page.