Event
Flight and expulsion of Palestinians, 1948
Flight or expulsion of 700,000 to 750,000 Palestinians in 1948, by Avi Shlaim's count. Palestinians call the events of 1948 the Nakba; historians differ on the causes.
- Dates
- 1947–1949
- Also known as
- Nakba, Palestinian exodus of 1948, Flight and expulsion of Arab residents, 1948
- One Land31 scenes
- Why did the flight and expulsion of Palestinians, 1948 happen?11 links, 5 accounts
- How are the flight and expulsion of Palestinians, 1948 and … connected?
According to Benny Morris
- interventions Haganah
- caused by "Transfer" in Zionist political thought
- caused by Israeli military orders and pressure, 1948
- caused by Israeli military orders and pressure, 1948
- caused by Israeli military orders and pressure, 1948
- caused by Arab orders to move dependents, and leaders' decisions, 1948
- influenced by Benny Morris
- located in Palestine (region)
According to Rashid Khalidi
- part of 1948 war
- influenced by Rashid Khalidi
- influenced by Rashid Khalidi
According to Avi Shlaim
- caused by Arab orders to move dependents, and leaders' decisions, 1948
- caused by Israeli military orders and pressure, 1948
- influenced by Avi Shlaim
- located in Palestine (region)
According to Walid Khalidi
- caused by Israeli military orders and pressure, 1948
- influenced by Walid Khalidi
According to Efraim Karsh
- caused by Arab orders to move dependents, and leaders' decisions, 1948
- caused by Arab orders to move dependents, and leaders' decisions, 1948
- influenced by David Ben-Gurion
- influenced by Efraim Karsh
- influenced by Efraim Karsh
According to Nur Masalha
- caused by "Transfer" in Zionist political thought
- influenced by Nur Masalha
- influenced by Nur Masalha
Connections 28
interventions
- Haganah According to Benny Morris Scholarship & press 1
part of
- 1948 war Primary record 2
- 1948 war According to Rashid Khalidi Scholarship & press 3
caused by
-
"Transfer" in Zionist political thought
According to Benny Morris
Scholarship & press
1
Morris, in a 2004 interview: no written order from Ben-Gurion himself, but "an atmosphere of [population] transfer".
- Israeli military orders and pressure, 1948 According to Benny Morris Scholarship & press 1
-
Israeli military orders and pressure, 1948
According to Benny Morris
Scholarship & press
1
Morris counts 24 massacres, "about a dozen" cases of rape, and about 800 killed in massacres and executions, from IDF archives; he also says that in his view the expulsions were not war crimes.
-
Arab orders to move dependents, and leaders' decisions, 1948
According to Avi Shlaim
Scholarship & press
4
The older Israeli account: Arab leaders ordered Palestinians to leave. Shlaim says Morris's 1988 research found no such calls. Walid Khalidi calls the claim a lie.
-
Israeli military orders and pressure, 1948
According to Walid Khalidi
Scholarship & press
5
Walid Khalidi reads the military operations of Plan D (April 1948) as one expulsion plan; Morris, in his words, sees no link between "transfer" talk and Plan Dalet.
- Arab orders to move dependents, and leaders' decisions, 1948 According to Efraim Karsh Scholarship & press 6
- Israeli military orders and pressure, 1948 According to Benny Morris Scholarship & press 1
- Arab orders to move dependents, and leaders' decisions, 1948 According to Benny Morris Scholarship & press 1
- Israeli military orders and pressure, 1948 According to Avi Shlaim Scholarship & press 4
- Arab orders to move dependents, and leaders' decisions, 1948 According to Efraim Karsh Scholarship & press 6
- "Transfer" in Zionist political thought According to Nur Masalha Scholarship & press 7
led to
- UN General Assembly Resolution 194 Primary record 8
- UN General Assembly Resolution 194 Primary record 2
influenced by
- Avi Shlaim According to Avi Shlaim Scholarship & press 4
-
Benny Morris
According to Benny Morris
Scholarship & press
1
Morris, in a 2004 interview, on the 1948 expulsions; he adds that he finds no justification for massacres or rape.
-
David Ben-Gurion
According to Efraim Karsh
Scholarship & press
6
A 1937 letter as Karsh quotes it; Morris, in 2004, calls Ben-Gurion "a transferist".
-
Efraim Karsh
According to Efraim Karsh
Scholarship & press
6
Karsh quotes a 1937 letter of Ben-Gurion and says Morris rendered it differently; Morris's answer is not read here.
- Efraim Karsh According to Efraim Karsh Scholarship & press 6
- Folke Bernadotte Primary record 2
- Nur Masalha According to Nur Masalha Scholarship & press 7
- Nur Masalha According to Nur Masalha Scholarship & press 7
- Rashid Khalidi According to Rashid Khalidi Scholarship & press 3
- Rashid Khalidi According to Rashid Khalidi Scholarship & press 9
- Walid Khalidi According to Walid Khalidi Scholarship & press 5
located in
-
Palestine (region)
According to Avi ShlaimAccording to Benny Morris
Scholarship & press
14
Shlaim: 700,000 to 750,000. Morris speaks of "700,000 Palestinians". The Mediator's 360,000 of September 1948 counted refugees "requiring aid".
Timeline 1 date
- 1947–1949 Flight and expulsion of Palestinians, 1948
Proof 9 sources
-
Survival of the Fittest? An interview with Benny Morris, by Ari Shavit (Haaretz, 9 January 2004), Haaretz, reprinted by Logos Journal, 9 Jan 2004.
Scholarship & press
In the months of April-May 1948, units of the Haganah [the pre-state defense force that was the precursor of the IDF] were given operational orders that stated explicitly that they were to uproot the villagers, expel them and destroy the villages themselves.
From April 1948, Ben-Gurion is projecting a message of transfer. There is no explicit order of his in writing, there is no orderly comprehensive policy, but there is an atmosphere of [population] transfer.
on October 31, 1948, the commander of the Northern Front, Moshe Carmel, issued an order in writing to his units to expedite the removal of the Arab population.
the expulsion order for the city of Lod, which was signed by Yitzhak Rabin
how many acts of Israeli massacre were perpetrated in 1948? Twenty-four.
if we take all the massacres and all the executions of 1948, we come to about 800 who were killed.
There is no explicit order of his in writing, there is no orderly comprehensive policy
it turns out that there was a series of orders issued by the Arab Higher Committee and by the Palestinian intermediate levels to remove children, women and the elderly from the villages.
Without the uprooting of the Palestinians, a Jewish state would not have arisen here.
Without the uprooting of the Palestinians
-
Progress Report of the United Nations Mediator on Palestine, 16 September 1948, The Avalon Project, Yale Law School, 16 Sep 1948.
Primary record
As a result of the conflict in Palestine there are approximately 360,000 Arab refugees and 7,000 Jewish refugees requiring aid
The right of the Arab refugees to return to their homes in Jewish controlled territory at the earliest possible date should be affirmed by the United Nations
approximately 360,000 Arab refugees and 7,000 Jewish refugees requiring aid
-
The Palestinians and 1948: the underlying causes of failure (chapter in The War for Palestine), Cambridge University Press (Cambridge Core), 2007.
Scholarship & press
Over this turbulent period, more than half of the nearly 1.4 million Palestinian Arabs were driven from or fled their homes.
Most conventional accounts of the 1948 War tend to focus on events after 15 May 1948, the date when the state of Israel was founded, and the Arab armies intervened unsuccessfully in Palestine in the wake of the stunning collapse of the Palestinians.
-
Israel's "new history" and the Palestinians (openDemocracy, via History News Network), History News Network.
Scholarship & press
The official Israeli version maintains that the Palestinians left the country on orders from their leaders and in the expectation of a triumphal return
He found no evidence of Arab calls on the Palestinians to leave their homes
there were many different reasons for the Palestinian exodus but the single most important reason was Israeli political, military, and psychological pressure.
Between 700,000 and 750,000 people, almost half the Arab population of Palestine, became refugees in 1948.
-
Plan Dalet: Master Plan for the Conquest of Palestine (Journal of Palestine Studies 18:1, with a 1988 introduction), Institute for Palestine Studies, Journal of Palestine Studies, 1988.
Scholarship & press
Archived copy
Zionism's responsibility for the Palestinian exodus and diaspora is an integral part of the genesis of the State of Israel.
the persistent official Israeli version of the events of 1948
-
Efraim Karsh takes Israel's "new historians" to task (History News Network), History News Network.
Scholarship & press
the collapse and dispersion of Palestinian society was largely the responsibility of Palestinian and other Arab leaders, not of the Zionists.
We do not wish and do not need to expel Arabs and take their place. All our aspiration is built on the assumption - proven throughout all our activity - that there is enough room for ourselves and the Arabs in Palestine.
The Israeli narrative views the Palestinian tragedy as primarily self-inflicted, resulting from their vehement rejection of the 1947 United Nations resolution calling for two states in Palestine, and the violent attempt by regional Arab states to abort the Jewish state at birth.
-
More land, fewer Arabs (interview with Nur Masalha), Carnegie Endowment for International Peace, Diwan, Oct 2019.
Scholarship & press
The expulsion of more than half of the Palestinian population in 1948 and the capture of 78 percent of Mandatory Palestine by and large ensured
the Palestinian Nakba, or “catastrophe,” of 1948
a large Palestinian minority survived within the Green Line, equivalent to 13 percent of the population in 1949
-
General Assembly Resolution 194 (III), 11 December 1948, The Avalon Project, Yale Law School, 11 Dec 1948.
Primary record
Resolves that the refugees wishing to return to their homes and live at peace with their neighbours should be permitted to do so at the earliest practicable date
-
The challenges of writing Palestinian history (adapted from The Iron Cage), History News Network, from the Boston Globe, 2006.
Scholarship & press
to ascribe agency to the Palestinians, to avoid seeing them either as no more than helpless victims of forces greater then themselves
Page history 2 changes
- Ask who benefited only where someone did, and not who is behind a country1bed08df
- Add 55 stories, each checked against its sources96e92fe6
Something wrong or missing? Tell us, with a source, or edit this page.