Concept
French royal debt and deficit
The crown's borrowing and the gap between its spending and its income, whose size and causes historians dispute.
According to Liberty, Equality, Fraternity: Exploring the French Revolution
- led to Assembly of Notables of 1787
According to 1990 Partisan Review essay on Schama's account of the Revolution
- followed from French intervention in the American war
According to Cambridge International AS Level History: Modern Europe, 1750-1921 Coursebook
- followed from French intervention in the American war
- influenced French Revolution
According to Eugene N. White
- influenced French Revolution
- influenced French Revolution
Connections 6
led to
followed from
-
French intervention in the American war
According to 1990 Partisan Review essay on Schama's account of the Revolution
Scholarship & press
2
The essay gives this as Simon Schama's view, and adds that he treats the debt as the result of decisions, not of the structure of French institutions.
- French intervention in the American war According to Cambridge International AS Level History: Modern Europe, 1750-1921 Coursebook Scholarship & press 3
influenced
-
French Revolution
According to Eugene N. White
Scholarship & press
4
White (1995) writes that most histories neglect the deficit, and that it shaped and prolonged the Revolution.
-
French Revolution
According to Eugene N. White
Scholarship & press
5
White (1989) argues these deficits only began in the mid-1780s, and does not mention the American war in his abstract.
- French Revolution According to Cambridge International AS Level History: Modern Europe, 1750-1921 Coursebook Scholarship & press 3
Proof 5 sources
-
Calonne, "Programs of Reform," Address to Assembly of Notables (1787), Roy Rosenzweig Center for History and New Media (George Mason University) and American Social History Project (CUNY), 22 Feb 1787.
Scholarship & press
By 1786, however, the deficit had become so huge—one–sixth of the total royal budget—that Calonne knew that reforms—meaning more taxes, or at least more loans—could no longer be put off.
To obtain the support of regional nobles for such changes, the King called an Assembly of Notables.
-
Partisan Review 57(3), 1990, p. 351: an essay on Simon Schama's account of the Revolution (page header: Susan Dunn), Partisan Review, Boston University, 1990.
Scholarship & press
the American affair was also the source of more debt for a regime already plagued by grave financial problems.
-
Cambridge International AS Level History: Modern Europe, 1750-1921 Coursebook, Chapter 1, France, 1774-1814 (excerpt), Cambridge University Press.
Scholarship & press
The United States became independent, but France gained nothing from the war except deeper national debt.
When the Notables demanded an accurate account of the royal finances, the king refused and instead dismissed the Assembly. This caused great anxiety and protest among the educated public, and marked the start of the financial and political crisis that eventually led to the revolution itself.
-
The French Revolution and the Politics of Government Finance, 1770-1815 (abstract), The Journal of Economic History, Cambridge University Press, 1995.
Scholarship & press
Although largely neglected in most histories of the French Revolution, the central government’s persistent budget deficit was a factor of paramount importance.
The struggle produced radical changes in macroeconomic policy to shift the burden of adjustment, altering the course of and prolonging the Revolution.
-
Was There a Solution to the Ancien Regime's Financial Dilemma? (abstract), The Journal of Economic History, Cambridge University Press, 1989.
Scholarship & press
While the collapse of the monarchy has been attributed to persistent peacetime deficits, these did not appear until the mid-1780s when earlier reforms and successful budget policies were abandoned by reactionary finance ministers.
Had the earlier policies been continued, it is unlikely that a severe crisis would have occurred in 1788/89.
Page history 1 change
- Add 55 stories, each checked against its sources96e92fe6
Something wrong or missing? Tell us, with a source, or edit this page.