From Clay to Print

Writing did not begin with poems or scripture. The earliest known writing kept accounts.

This story follows one line from those accounts to a printed Bible about 4,700 years later, by way of an alphabet, the oldest surviving copies, two translations and a press.

It is one line among many. Writing in Asia is not thought to come from Sumer, and movable type came first in China and Korea. Belief is told here as belief and scholarship as scholarship, and where a step rests on one tradition or one scholar, the story says so. A connection is not evidence of influence.

c. 3200 BCE

Two dots

A clay tablet in Uruk, about 3200 BCE. A printed Bible in Mainz, about 1455. Some 4,700 years lie between them, and every step of the way between can be checked.

c. 3200 BCE

Bread and beer

Around 3200 BCE the temple estates of Uruk, in today’s Iraq, needed to keep accounts. Scribes drew signs on clay to track rations of bread and beer. The earliest known writing was bookkeeping.

First developed by scribes as a bookkeeping tool to keep track of bread and beer rations in ancient cities like Uruk (in the south east of modern-day Iraq)
British Museum, How to write cuneiform, 21 January 2021. Scholarship & press. Open the source Archived copy

c. 1800 BCE

Letters

Signs at Serabit el-Khadim, an Egyptian mining site in Sinai, are often taken as the start of the alphabet, made by Semitic speakers. Scholars date them from the nineteenth century BCE to after 1500 BCE. The date is still disputed.

The date for the development of early alphabetic script is still disputed
Felix Höflmayer and colleagues, Antiquity, 2021. Scholarship & press. Open the source

c. 1000 BCE

By sea

The oldest surviving Phoenician inscription is the Ahiram epitaph at Byblos, from the eleventh century BCE. Phoenician traders spread the script across the Mediterranean, and Greeks adopted it. Early Hebrew writing varies little from the same family of alphabets.

Perhaps the most significant contribution of the Phoenicians was an alphabetic writing system that became the root of the Western alphabets when the Greeks adopted it.
Metropolitan Museum of Art, The Phoenicians, 2004. Scholarship & press. Open the source Archived copy

The tradition’s account

Who wrote the Torah, the first five books of the Bible? According to Jewish tradition, Moses did, having received them from God on Mount Sinai. The text itself says that Moses wrote down the law.

And Moses wrote this law, and delivered it unto the priests the sons of Levi, that bore the ark of the covenant of the LORD, and unto all the elders of Israel.
Deuteronomy 31:9, Jewish Publication Society translation, 1917. Primary record. Open the source

The scholars’ account

Modern source criticism reads the same books as woven from older documents, from about the tenth to the sixth century BCE, as Christine Hayes of Yale sums it up. Scholars still differ on the sources and dates. Neither account is stated here as fact.

the Torah is really the result of five centuries of religious and literary activity.
Christine Hayes, Yale University, lecture, 2006. Scholarship & press. Open the source

c. 100 BCE

The oldest copies

The Dead Sea Scrolls, found near Qumran, date from the third century BCE to the first century CE. They hold every book of the Hebrew Bible but Esther. Many of the biblical scrolls closely resemble the text in use today, and some differ.

Over 1,000 yearsHow much older the scrolls are than the biblical manuscripts known before them

This similarity is quite remarkable, considering that the Qumran Scrolls are over a thousand years older than previously identified biblical manuscripts.
The Dead Sea Scrolls: Introduction, Israel Antiquities Authority (Leon Levy Dead Sea Scrolls Digital Library). Primary record. Open the source

c. 250 BCE

Into Greek

The Letter of Aristeas tells how the king of Egypt sent to Jerusalem for six elders from every tribe, and how they put the Jewish law into Greek in seventy-two days. This translation is known as the Septuagint.

72 daysHow long 72 elders took to put the law into Greek, according to the Letter of Aristeas

it so chanced that the work of translation was completed in seventy-two days, just as if this had been arranged of set purpose.
The Letter of Aristeas (R. H. Charles, ed.), Christian Classics Ethereal Library (Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1913), 1913. Primary record. Open the source

c. 250 BCE

What the language shows

Encyclopaedia Britannica calls the Letter of Aristeas unreliable. Analysis of the Greek places the Torah’s translation near the middle of the third century BCE, and the rest of the Old Testament in the second.

Analysis of the language has established that the Torah, or Pentateuch (the first five books of the Old Testament), was translated near the middle of the 3rd century bce and that the rest of the Old Testament was translated in the 2nd century bce.
Encyclopaedia Britannica, Septuagint. Scholarship & press. Open the source

386

Into Latin

In 382 Pope Damasus asked Jerome for one acceptable Latin Bible. Settled in Bethlehem by 386, Jerome turned from the Greek to the Hebrew and finished his Old Testament by the end of 405. His Latin became known as the Vulgate.

By the end of 405 he had executed his own Latin translation of the entire Old Testament based on the “Hebrew truth” (Hebraica veritas).
Robert M. Grant, Encyclopaedia Britannica. Scholarship & press. Open the source

1455

Into type

Around 1455 in Mainz, Johannes Gutenberg printed Jerome’s Latin with movable metal type. Counts of the edition differ: Cornell’s library says about 200 copies, the Library of Congress at least 120 on paper and perhaps 40 on vellum.

48Gutenberg Bibles known to survive, by Cornell's count

It is thought that Gutenberg printed 165 copies on paper and thirty-five copies on parchment. Of this total, only forty-eight Gutenberg Bibles are known to have survived.
Gutenberg Bible (Paper, Leather, Clay & Stone, online exhibition), Cornell University Library. Scholarship & press. Open the source

1455

First elsewhere

Gutenberg’s type was not the first. Movable type and paper began in China, and the oldest surviving book printed that way came from Korea. According to Robert Lechêne, a small alphabet of abstract signs made such type simpler to use in Europe.

Movable type and paper were invented in China, and the oldest known extant book printed from movable type was created in Korea in the 14th century.
Encyclopaedia Britannica, Printing press. Scholarship & press. Open the source Archived copy

1534

And after

Within fifty years of Gutenberg’s page, more than ten million printed books had been produced. In 1534 Martin Luther’s complete Bible was printed at Wittenberg, and its printer is said to have sold over 100,000 copies in forty years.

Over 10 millionPrinted books made within fifty years of Gutenberg's page

In less than fifty years after the printing of this page, more than ten million printed books had been produced.
Gutenberg Bible (Paper, Leather, Clay & Stone, online exhibition), Cornell University Library. Scholarship & press. Open the source

1534

One line

This line shows the order of the story, not a road anyone walked. Two of its steps rest on one scholar’s account each, and every step shows its proof. A connection is not evidence of influence.